GL Best & Worst Poll of 1998

Best Storyline | Best Actor | Best Actress | Best Couple | Best Newcomer | Best Recast | Best Returnee | Best Triangle | Best Villian | Best Villianess | Favorite Female Character | Favorite Male Character | Best Storyline | Worst Newcomer | Worst Actress | Worst Actor | Worst Storyline | Worst Couple | Worst Recast | Worst Returnee | Worst Triangle | Complete Poll Results | Polling Guidelines

GL Best Actor

Justin Deas (Buzz Cooper) is top dog this year. His performance during Jenna's death scenes were powerful, to put it mildly. It was a good reminder of why he's received six Emmy awards. He hasn't had a lot to work with this year, storyline-wise. But when given the material, he always delivers. He received 458 of 1686 votes (27%). The rest of the top five: Grant Aleksander (Phillip, 296 votes or 18%), Robert Newman (Josh, 251 votes or 15%), Hunt Block (Ben, 217 votes or 13%), and Jerry ver Dorn (Ross, 188 votes or 11%).

Interesting note: There were 19 actors mentioned in this poll category, with Hunt Block voted fourth best. Last year Hunt Block was voted GL's second worst actor!

GL Best Actress

Kim Zimmer (Reva) was chosen as the best actress with 433 votes or 26% of the total. Beth Ehlers (Harley), clearly a fan favorite, came in second place (23% or 388 votes). Rounding out the top five: Wendy Moniz (Dinah, 12% or 205 votes), Laura Wright (Cassie, 152 votes or 9%), and Fiona Hutchison (Jenna, 116 votes or 7%).

GL Best Couple

For the second year in a row, Phillip and Harley were chosen GL's best couple. They received 926 votes, 53% of the total! Tied for second was Josh and Reva (13% or 217 votes) and Cassie and Hart (13% or 227 votes). Fourth was Buzz and Jenna (6% or 110 votes). Matt and Vanessa were fifth with 58 votes or 3%. My favorite write in votes: the two people who are still holding out hope against all hope who voted for Beth and Phillip.

GL Best Newcomer

There is no doubt Sean McCullough will be missed in Springfield. He was chosen as GL's best newcomer with 713 votes or 45% of the total. Second was Selena Davis with 456 votes or 29%. My favorite write in vote: teen Cleva.

GL Best Recast

Fans chose Joie Lenz as the best recast of 1998. She replaced Rebecca Budig as Michelle Bauer. Joie received 52% of the votes (321). Second place went to Signy Coleman (Annie, 116 votes or 19%). Funniest write in vote: Amy Carlson for replacing Beth Ehlers for a few episodes. The fan who sent that in definitely isn't a Beth Ehlers fan!

GL Best Returnee

Alexandra Spaulding (47% or 291 votes) and India von Halkein (32% or 200 votes) were overwhelmingly chosen the best returnees of 1998. Ken Norris received 11% of the votes (66). Annie Dutton's return was liked by 8% of the fans (52 votes) and David Grant's by 2% (9 votes). If the roles of Annie and David were not recast when they returned, they probably would have fared better (given a decent storyline).

GL Best Triangle

Hart/Cassie/Dinah was chosen as the best triangle of 1998 with 572 votes (39%). Ben/Blake/Ross came in second with 407 votes or 25%. Third was Beth/Phillip/Harley in third with 367 votes or 22%. My favorite write-in vote for best triangle: Josh/Cassie/Annie!

GL Best Villian

Ben Warren is going strong as GL's best villian, according to the fans. He received 67% of the vote (401). Alan Spaulding came in second with 138 votes or 23%.

GL Best Villianess

She took her mother's blood pressure pills, set a fire in her bedroom, and had a one-night stand in order to get pregnant this past year, all to keep Hart to herself. Who was it? None other than Dinah Marler. She was voted GL's Best Villianess with 328 votes or 44% of the total. Second place was Annie Dutton with 17% or 124 votes.

GL Favorite Female Character

She was named after a motorcyle and grew up on Fifth Street. Dinah Marler helped deliver her first child. She's none other than Harley Cooper - your choice as favorite female character. Harley received 270 out of 731 votes (37%). Reva Shayne (126 votes) and Cassie Layne (125 votes) statistically tied for second place with 17% of the votes each.

GL Favorite Male Character

Was there any doubt Phillip would be number one for favorite male character? He received 171 votes or 27%. Second place went to Buzz with 95 votes.


GL Worst Couple

Poor Jesse and Michelle, they get no respect. They led this category with 590 votes. Thirty-five percent voted for them. Hart and Dinah came in second with 429 votes. My pick for best write in vote: Josh and clone Reva.

GL Worst Recast & GL Worst Returnee

With extremely tough shoes to fill and playing to a tough crowd, Signy Coleman as Annie Dutton was chosen as the worst recast of 1998. She received 238 votes or 35% of the total. The return of Annie Dutton was also chosen as the worst returnee of the year, with 274 of 522 votes (52%).

GL Worst Triangle

Statistically it's a tie, but Annie/Josh/Reva "wins" the category by 6 votes, beating Jesse/Michelle/Drew. The continuation of this triangle (voted as the best triangle for 1997) was not welcomed by many. Annie/Josh/Reva received 468 votes, Jesse/Michelle/Drew received 462. Third place went to Matt/Beth/Vanessa with 243 votes. My favorite write in vote was for Buzz/Nola/Jenna. Granted, Nola did leave the show in 1998, but is someone still rolling their eyes from the "Nola stalking Buzz" story?!

GL Worst Newcomer

Vicky Spaulding was voted GL's worst newcomer (33% or 366 votes). Rob Layne came in second with 330 votes (30%). Rebuilding the Spauldings is an idea many fans like, but this character isn't catching on.

GL Worst Actress:

Victoria Platt (Vicky Spaulding) was voted as GL's worst actress, receiving 135 out of 544 votes (25%). Rebecca Budig (ex-Michelle Bauer) came in second place with 96 votes (18%). The rest of the top five: Signy Coleman (Annie, 72 votes or 13%), Beth Chamberlin (Beth, 44 votes or 8%), and Lauren Mayhew (Marah, 32 votes or 6%).

GL Worst Actor:

For the second year in a row Paulo Benedeti (Jesse Blue) was chosen as GL's worst actor. He received 141 votes or 28%. There were 510 total votes in this category. The rest of the top five: Ryan Brown (Bill Lewis, with 84 votes or 16%), Frank Grillo (Hart Jessup, with 44 votes or 9%), Kevin Mambo (ex-Marcus, with 32 votes or 6%), and Terrell Tilford (David Grant, with 27 votes or 5%).

GL Best Storyline for 1998

Forty-six different happenings were named during polling for this category. A total of 683 votes was received. With 28% of the total or 190 votes, the romance of Phillip and Harley was picked as the best storyline for 1998. Another 47 people specifically mentioned their wedding, which was considered a separate happening. They are tops, no doubt about it! Coming in second as best story with 52 votes was Teri being Annie, followed by the Pharley wedding (47 votes), and cloning Reva (46 votes).

GL Worst Storyline for 1998

With 719 votes received, there were three main storylines mentioned as worst for 1998: the cloning of Reva (159 votes), Teri being Annie (121 votes), and Michelle's blindness (104 votes). Twenty-percent of the fans said "just shouldn't have done it" when it came to cloning. Farewell Dolly.

Polling Guidelines

Polling for the best and worst of 1998 on Guiding Light was done via e-mail. Over 20,000 votes were received in twenty categories. This poll is not scientific and reflects only the opinions of those GL fans who chose to participate. The results cannot be assumed to represent the opinions of GL fans in general, nor the public as a whole.

Certain characters or actors were chosen to be invalid for particular categories. Here is an explanation:

  1. Best/Worst Storyline: Had to have happened in 1998.
  2. Best/Worst Actor/Actress: Had to have appeared for a significant amount of time on Guiding Light in 1998 and/or been on the show (either as a recurring or contract player) at the end of the year.
  3. Best/Worst Character/Villian: Had to have appeared on Guiding Light in 1998. Vote is for the character only.
  4. Best/Worst Newcomer: Role had to have originated in 1998. For the purposes of this poll the role of Susan Lemay was considered a new one, since the character was a small child when she last appeared.
  5. Best/Worst Recast: A character that returned to the show that had been in Springfield previously.
  6. Best/Worst Returnee: A character that came back to Springfield that had lived in town before.

Voting guidelines were sent to all those polled. In case of confusion of how votes were tallied, here are the guidelines on what votes were deemed invalid and were not counted:

  1. Only one vote per e-mail address per category was allowed.
  2. Any vote that did not have the category and the choice in the subject line was not counted. Anything typed in the message area of the vote was ignored.
  3. Any vote that had multiple categories in the subject line was not counted.
  4. If more than one vote for the same category was sent in from the same e-mail address only the most recent vote was kept (based on hour/minute sent).
  5. If the hour/minute was the same on different multiple votes in the same category, all votes were discarded.
  6. Votes for "none" were not counted.

In order to avoid confusion between characters that were recast, fans who don't know the real names of the actor playing certain roles, and also due to the passing of Michael Zaslow, some decisions about the poll were made: These are:

  1. Michael Zaslow did not appear on Guiding Light in 1998. Votes for him were not counted. Zaslow was a wonderful performer and Roger was a great villian, but this poll was for 1998 only.
  2. Since the role of Annie Dutton has been recast and Cynthia Watros played the role for only a short time in 1998, it was decided to not include Cynthia Watros as a valid choice for any category for the 1998 poll.
  3. Votes for Roger Thorpe were counted, as the character did appear on the show in 1998. However, these votes were for the Roger as played by Dennis Parlato.
  4. Votes for Annie Dutton were counted, as the character did appear on the show in 1998. However, these votes were for the Annie as played by Signy Coleman.

Obviously it is very important to each voter that their vote is counted for the character and/or actor they mean it to be for. Since some actors are so closely associated with a role, I hope these guidelines clear up any confusion.

Best and Worst of 1997 Poll
GL News & Previews Main Page
Soap News Main Page
This page last updated 1/18/99.